Money & Business

Hiring Your First Employee in Indiana: A Trainer's Checklist

Women greeting with a handshake in an office, a welcome for a first employee at an Indiana small business

Hiring your first employee in Indiana means getting a federal employer number, registering for state withholding and unemployment insurance, carrying workers compensation, collecting the right forms and reporting the hire to the state within 20 days. It is a short list, but the order matters, because each step needs details from the one before it. If you are a trainer who has built a practice in rented hourly space and is ready to add a coach or front-desk helper, this checklist keeps the paperwork from stalling the hire.

Step 0: confirm the person is an employee

Everything below applies only if the worker is an employee. The classification question comes first, and the assistant trainer decision walks through it. Indiana’s unemployment guidance says a contract and a 1099 do not settle the matter, so do not hire as a contractor to avoid this list unless the facts support it.

The checklist in order

Step What you do Where
1 Get an employer identification number IRS
2 Register for state withholding Indiana Department of Revenue
3 Register for unemployment insurance Indiana Department of Workforce Development
4 Arrange workers compensation coverage Insurance carrier, Workers’ Compensation Board rules
5 Collect the I-9, federal W-4 and state withholding forms Employee, on or before the first paycheck
6 Report the new hire State new hire directory
7 Set up payroll deposits, filings and records Payroll provider or CPA

Steps one and two: the numbers

The IRS says you need an employer identification number if you have employees or will pay employment taxes. A sole proprietor who has operated under a personal number can apply for one, and an entity needs its own.

Indiana requires withholding agents to register with the Department of Revenue, using Form BT-1 with no fee, and to withhold state income tax and county income tax where applicable. If you are already registered for another tax type, you add withholding when you add your first employee. Because county tax depends on where each employee lives, collect the state’s exemption and county status certificate from every hire.

Step three: unemployment insurance

The Department of Workforce Development says a new employer that has paid $1 or more to a worker performing covered services in Indiana should register through its Employer Self Service site. You will need the employer number, legal name, a business classification code, a mailing address, the location of the work, the date of the first payroll payment and an identifier for the responsible party.

After registration, wages are reported to the agency each quarter. If you later find you misclassified someone, the department’s guidance is to report the worker immediately and adjust prior reports back to the start date.

Step four: workers compensation

Indiana’s Workers’ Compensation Board says the law requires most businesses with employees to carry coverage, and that employers can show compliance through a policy with an authorized carrier or by proving financial ability to self-insure. The board enforces proof-of-coverage rules with penalties, so keep your certificate where you can find it quickly.

A solo trainer with no employees has a different answer, and the sole proprietor page explains where it changes. Talk to an insurance agent before the first day, because coverage should be active when the first shift begins.

What the rule says

The IRS requires employers to complete Form I-9 for every hire and to ask new employees for a signed Form W-4. The Indiana Department of Revenue requires withholding agents to register and withhold state and county tax. The Department of Workforce Development requires registration once covered wages are paid and electronic reporting of new hires within 20 days of the hire or rehire date. The Workers’ Compensation Board states that the law requires most businesses to carry coverage. Sources: IRS hiring employees page, Indiana DOR withholding page, Indiana DWD employer pages and the Workers’ Compensation Board, checked October 2026. This is general information, not legal or tax advice, and rules change; confirm each step with the agency or a CPA.

Steps five to seven: forms, reporting and routine

Collect the employee’s forms on or before the first day. The IRS says to ask each new employee for a signed Form W-4 when they start, and that if none is provided you withhold as if the employee is single until it arrives. The Form I-9 verifies eligibility to work, and the IRS states that employers must complete it for every person they hire.

The state’s new hire report covers the employee’s name, address, Social Security number, date of hire, date of birth, medical insurance eligibility, job title, starting pay and rate of pay, and it is due electronically within 20 days of the hire date.

After that, payroll becomes a rhythm: withhold, deposit, file the quarterly forms and send a Form W-2 at year end. Many small employers pass this to a payroll provider so that deadlines do not slip.

Costs and structure to plan for

Budget for more than wages. Employer payroll tax matches part of the employee’s, unemployment contributions apply, and workers compensation carries a premium. A CPA can model the first year, including whether the numbers justify a hire now or a few months out.

An entity may also be worth discussing. The Indiana legal checklist covers LLC basics, and the S corporation comparison becomes relevant once you run payroll, since owners paying themselves wages is part of that decision.

A last pass before day one

  • Classification decided and written down.
  • Employer number received.
  • Withholding and unemployment accounts open.
  • Workers compensation active.
  • Forms collected, new hire reported, records folder created.

Work through the table from the top, and put the 20-day reporting date in your calendar the day you set the start date.

Related questions

Do I need all of these registrations before the first day or the first paycheck?

Do the registrations before the first payroll. The state's unemployment agency asks you to register once you have paid a worker for covered services, and withholding should be set up before you pay anyone, so the safe habit is to finish the list before day one.

Can I run payroll myself or should I use a provider?

Either works for one employee. Doing it yourself saves a fee but takes recurring attention, and a provider or CPA handles deposits and filings on a schedule. Choose based on how much you want to keep on your own calendar.

Does hiring change how I should be set up as a business?

It can. An entity may protect personal assets and an owner with employees has new exposures, so a CPA or attorney should look at structure before the first hire, not after.

Ready when you are

Ready to be your own boss?

Your first hour in a FlexSpace is free. Create your free Fit Pro account and claim it today. No leases, no long-term commitments. Or talk to our pro team first.

Instagram

Follow the werk

Talk to our AI Live
AI Chat Assistant×

Welcome!

Meet Rex, your 24/7 AI assistant. He's here to help you explore how FlexWerk Space can support your training business and answer any questions you have. Choose how you'd like to connect:

Call or Talk Live with Rex, Our AI Voice Guide
Want a real conversation over the phone +1 888 316-6530 or online? Rex can speak with you directly through your browser. No downloads..., no wait times. Ask about renting private training spaces by the hour, equipment, availability, booking, insurance requirements, or co-working options for fitness professionals. Rex is ready for a one-on-one conversation with you right now. Read more..

Chat Instantly with Rex, Your AI Assistant
Prefer texting? Rex is your instant guide for answers, information, and a walkthrough of what FlexWerk Space offers.... Ask about private training spaces, hourly rates, availability, or how to get started. Rex will respond in real time to help you find the right fit. Read more..